Simply Jess and Bain Marie

At The Gatehouse Coffee Shop, we love supporting local artisans — and our pastry case is full of proof. One of our favorites comes from Simply Jess, a talented baker from Otego, NY, who works alongside her mother, Bain Marie. Together, they craft cookies, seasonal pastries, and other baked treats with care, attention to detail, and a lot of love.

Each pastry is handcrafted, highlighting both artistry and flavor, making them the perfect companion to a morning coffee or an afternoon treat. From sweet, classic chocolate chip cookies to flaky baklava pastries, every bite reflects their dedication to quality and craft.

Stop by The Gatehouse to experience these local creations for yourself — it’s more than a pastry; it’s a little taste of home and heart in every bite.